SEC and CFTC release new regulatory framework, raising challenges to the legislative necessity of the CLARITY Act

BTC1,87%
ETH2,56%
DOGE2,26%

Gate News reports that on March 18, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) jointly issued an interpretive guidance document, systematically delineating the regulatory framework for digital assets. This move is seen by the market as a substantial alternative to the “Digital Asset Market Transparency Act” (CLARITY Act).

The document proposes a classification system for five types of tokens, including digital commodities, digital collectibles, digital tools, stablecoins, and digital securities, with only digital securities falling under securities regulation. Mainstream assets like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Dogecoin are explicitly categorized as digital commodities, further reducing regulatory uncertainty.

Regarding the division of regulatory responsibilities, the new framework continues the previous contentious point: CFTC oversees the spot market for digital commodities, while the SEC regulates digital securities. Additionally, the guidance clarifies the compliance boundaries for activities such as staking, airdrops, and mining, and introduces the “add-on and separation” principle, providing a pathway for projects to transition from securities to non-securities.

Notably, the content overlaps significantly with the CLARITY Act, including token classification logic and the division of regulatory authority. Some market participants believe that regulators have already completed about 80% of the rule-making without legislation, reducing the urgency for the bill to pass. Analysts MartyParty and Ryan Adams, co-founders of Bankless, both point out that this guidance already covers the main functions of the bill.

However, the interpretive document has limitations. The CLARITY Act involves registration requirements for trading platforms, compliance frameworks for brokers, and anti-money laundering enforcement mechanisms, which are not yet included in the current guidance. Moreover, the guidance is not legally binding and may be adjusted due to policy changes in the future, whereas formal legislation would offer greater stability and enforceability.

Currently, the U.S. Congress is still debating key issues such as stablecoin yield mechanisms, and related legislation has been delayed. While the regulators’ proactive measures have alleviated industry uncertainty, whether they can serve as a long-term substitute for a legal framework remains to be seen.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to Disclaimer.

Related Articles

Trump Signals Openness: Consider a Currency Swap With the UAE, Extending “Wartime Dollar Diplomacy” Further

CNBC reported that Trump publicly said he would help if needed, considering establishing a currency swap channel with the UAE, marking the White House’s first public response on the issue. The UAE central bank governor visited the U.S. last week to raise the possibility, but the actual decision still rests with the U.S. Federal Reserve. Fighting in the Strait of Hormuz disrupts dollar liquidity; if it goes ahead, it would broaden the impact of dollar diplomacy and on crypto, stablecoins, and global inflation/exchange rates.

ChainNewsAbmedia1h ago

Bank of Korea Prioritizes CBDCs Under New Governor Shin, Maintains 2.5% Rate Amid Regional Uncertainty

Gate News message, April 22 — South Korea's central bank has entered a new monetary phase with newly appointed governor Shin Hyun-song placing central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) at the forefront of the country's financial system. In his inaugural address, Shin positioned CBDCs and bank-issued d

GateNews1h ago

Indonesia's Central Bank Holds Key Rate at 4.75%, Pledges Further FX Intervention

Gate News message, April 22 — Indonesia's central bank maintained its benchmark interest rate at 4.75% on April 22, marking the seventh consecutive meeting without a change and aligning with market expectations. Central Bank Governor Perry Warjiyo stated that the bank has intensified foreign

GateNews2h ago

Fed Chair Nominee Kevin Warsh Backs Crypto Integration, Opposes CBDC

Abstract: Trump's Fed chair nominee Kevin Warsh argues digital assets are already part of U.S. finance, rejects a central bank digital currency, and favors market-led crypto innovation. He disclosed more than $100 million in crypto holdings, inviting questions about independence. Summary: Warsh, Trump's Fed nominee, says digital assets are integral to U.S. finance, rejects a CBDC, and favors market-driven crypto innovation; he disclosed more than $100 million in crypto holdings, raising independence concerns.

GateNews5h ago

Trump’s nominee for Fed chair: won’t be a White House puppet—crypto assets will become the new financial normal

Warsh emphasized the Federal Reserve’s independence at the hearing, denied being a White House puppet, and did not commit to rate cuts; if he takes office or adopts a more accommodative policy, it would be positive for risk assets such as Bitcoin. U.S. stocks fell amid the hearing and geopolitical risks, with the three major indexes down by about 0.6%. Changes in Middle East talks also intensified market risk sentiment.

ChainNewsAbmedia6h ago

Trump Nominates Christopher Fehren as White House Economic Advisers Chair

Gate News message, April 22 — President Trump nominated Christopher Fehren as chair of the White House Council of Economic Advisers on April 21, filling the vacancy left by former chair Stephen Miran after his appointment as a member of the Federal Reserve Board in 2025. The nomination has been

GateNews8h ago
Comment
0/400
No comments