If it weren't for the timed Red Envelopes, everyone would be watching broadcasts, learning trading strategies, watching good analysis, and trading. Timed envelopes have come out, now people are browsing the broadcasts with red envelopes, checking the duration, waiting there, taking the red envelope and going to the other publication with the red envelope with a decreasing duration. There was also a follower envelope, now publishers throw this envelope so that my followers increase, people follow to get this envelope, they take the consumable, they do not come to that publication again because everyone can only get the follower envelope once. I think the timed envelope and the Follower envelope are very bad for both the streamer and the person who actually watches the stream. He can't get a red envelope because of the people who are chasing the envelope who watch the real broadcast. Those who receive envelopes in the broadcast go to other publications, no one watches.